- Home
- About
- Practice Areas
- Business and Corporate Law
- Business Formation and Structuring
- Asset and Stock Purchases and Sales
- Trademark and Copyright
- Mergers & Acquisitions
- Business Valuations and Buyouts
- Business Financing and SBA Loans
- General Counsel Services
- Founders Agreements
- Shareholder Agreements
- Non-Compete, Non-Solicitation, and Non-Disclosure Contracts
- Joint Venture Agreements
- Licensing
- Asset Protection
- Franchise Agreements
- Business Dissolution and Restructuring
- Business and Commercial Litigation
- Real Estate
- Real Estate Fraud & NVAR Residential Sales Contracts
- Construction Disputes & Mechanics Liens
- New Home Construction and Builder Contract Disputes
- Asset Protection
- Easements
- Boundary Line Disputes
- Quiet Title Actions
- Adverse Possession Claims
- Injunctions, Nuisance, and Trespass Claims
- Title Litigation
- Real Estate Deeds
- New Deed Request
- Commercial Property Acquisitions, Sales, and Development
- Commercial Leasing Disputes
- Landlord-Tenant Disputes
- Real Estate Brokers & Agents
- Condominiums, HOA & Cooperatives Law
- Partition/Allotment Actions
- Mold, Asbestos, and Toxic Torts Defense
- Hard Money Loan Agreements
- Real Estate Investors
- Property Managers
- Wholesaling Agreements
- Estate Planning
- Estate and Trust Litigation
- Business and Corporate Law
- Media
- Blog
- Contact Us
703-652-5506
Recent Blog Posts
What Is "Substantial Economic Effect" In LLC Operating Agreements?
As more and more investors resort to LLCs to structure their business ventures, particularly in real estate, the requirement for a carefully formulated Operating Agreement is vital. Yet, one often sees inexperienced lawyers and investors fall victim to templated Operating Agreements full of nonsensical, boilerplate language.
One such critical concept often misunderstood or ignored is "substantial economic effect," a key principle of tax law that determines how LLCs allocate profits and losses to their members. Failing to address this can result in significant financial and legal implications for the members of the LLC. This blog explores what substantial economic effect means, how to identify and correct flaws in typical LLC Operating Agreements, and how ignoring these principles can leave members, particularly real estate investors, at a disadvantage.
What is Substantial Economic Effect?
Substantial economic effect refers to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) standard that governs whether the allocation of profits, losses, and distributions in an LLC is valid for tax purposes. To comply with this standard, the allocations must reflect real economic consequences for the members, not just paper entries. You can read the exact guidance by the IRS on this issue here and here. The key elements of substantial economic effect are:
Choosing the Right Business Entity: A Comprehensive Comparison
Selecting the right business entity is one of the most critical decisions for entrepreneurs and business owners. The choice between an LLC, S Corporation, C Corporation, or Partnership has far-reaching implications on liability, taxation, management structure, capital raising, and compliance requirements. A well-informed decision can optimize tax efficiency, protect personal assets, and ensure operational flexibility.
To help business owners navigate this complex decision-making process, we’ve provided a detailed side-by-side comparison of these entity types, outlining their key characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages.
Choice of Entity Comparison
| Entity | Limited Liability Company (LLC) | S Corporation | C Corporation | Partnership |
| Description | Can be formed by state filing; members manage directly or delegate to managers. Default tax treatment as partnership unless otherwise elected. | Corporation that meets IRS requirements for pass-through taxation. Limited to 100 U.S. shareholders and one class of stock. | Traditional corporate structure with shareholders. Subject to double taxation (corporate and individual levels). | Formed by oral or written agreement (General Partnership) or state filing (Limited Partnership). Pass-through taxation. |
